Forums > Senate Hall archive > I'm planning on adding a 'pros and cons of lightsaber styles' page... any ideas/input/info?

I'm going to put it all on a microsoft excel worksheet complete w/ saber styles, descriptions, pros, and cons.heres what it looks like so far...

Type of Saber Description Pros Cons _________________________________________________




Fiber Linked



ok, nevermind, apparently wookiepedia doesnt accept xls formated documents. but here's what i got from copying and pasting. i need all the info and suggestions i can get. thanks! Unsigned comment by Darth stigma (talk • contribs).

  • This really looks like it would be a large amount original research, which would not be a good thing. If you can source what goes in it, fine, but I really doubt that this can't be covered in the individual articles devoted to each type of lightsaber or lightsaber combat. Wildyoda 13:39, 15 March 2007 (UTC)
    • As a major patroller of the 7 forms pages, I can tell you that original research is something I see on those pages a lot. It's not tolerated at all, and unless your work has been licensed by Lucasfilm, I frankly don't want to see it on those pages. Period. Sorry to be harsh, but I've dealt with this a lot. On the bright side of things, this November, a new Essential Guide to the Force will be coming out, that will talk more about the saber forms hopefully. Atarumaster88 Jedi Order (Audience Chamber) 04:20, 16 March 2007 (UTC)
      • But I'm sure there's no problem if you add that suff to your userpage. KEJ 08:13, 16 March 2007 (UTC)