Talk:Attack of the Phantom

From Wookieepedia, the Star Wars wiki.

Will the Phantom Editor ever grace us with an Episode 3 edit? I think that Episode 3 was pretty good, but it suffered from Anakin's turn to the dark side being too abrupt, some frivelous special effects shots, and some very stupid lines before the final duel.

Even if the rest of the movie were un-changed, the two big lines that I always felt the most uncomfortable with were "Anakin, you're breaking my heart!" and "Only a sith deals in absolutes!" The latter line was completely out of character for a Jedi to say, because the opposite is true. Sith believe that morality is relative, and that the universe is nothing but a shade of gray. Jedi have a very clear sense of absolute good and absolute evil, so Obi Wan was talking BS. I'm sure the Phantom Editor would pick up on that, along with a dozen other things that I wouldn't even realize the movie is better without.