Talk:Lumas Etima

From Wookieepedia, the Star Wars wiki.

[edit] Niman

Since its been stated elsewhere that all Niman practitioners present at the Battle of Geonosis were killed, can we take that to mean that Etima's fate is "worm food" rather than "unknown?" Jwebb13^HoloNet 05:18, 12 November 2006 (UTC)

• The Battle of Geonosis article lists Etima among those Jedi KIA'd, and Form VI: Niman confirms that "all of the Form VI practitioners at the Battle of Geonosis were killed," so I'm going to change the Lumas Etima article to reflect this. If anyone disagrees, I'd be happy to discuss it. Jwebb13^HoloNet 22:56, 12 November 2006 (UTC)
  • We know that all the Form VI practitioners at Geonosis were killed, but nothing says that all Jedi killed at Geonosis were Form VI practitioners. All of Theed is Naboo, but not all of Naboo is Theed. Does a source claim he preferred Form VI? (For all we know he could have favoured Makashi. I still maintain that, had there been any Makashi practioners fighting in that battle, they would have all been gunned down much more quickly than the Nimanites. The only reason all the Makashi users weren't killed at Geonosis was because the only one was standing safe on a balcony. Niman only taught a little about blaster deflection; Makashi downright neglected it.) -BaronGrackle 14:47, 19 November 2006 (UTC)