AppearancesEdit

In his article, Valin is listed as only being mentioned in Abyss. He actually appeared, (though frozen in carbonite). Does this count as an appearance or just a mention? ZEM talk to me! 06:26, September 4, 2009 (UTC)

• It should be counted as an appearance since he actually appeared in person. If he was just mentioned, he'd be spoken of in dialect. —Unsigned comment by 99.3.117.53 (talk • contribs).

UpdateEdit

Can someone update this page to reflect Conviction, especially what happens to Valin up to and after his duel with Ben. It needs to be done. Senjuto 12:12, 12 June 2011 (UTC)