FANDOM


This subpage contains instructions on how to archive past Comprehensive Article nominations. The archived votes can be found here.

Successful nominationsEdit

Once an article has a total of three EduCorps votes or two EduCorps votes and three user votes after at least one week (or four EduCorps votes after at least 48 hours) and no outstanding objections, the article can be officially known as a "comprehensive article." This table can be used to determine if an article is eligible to be removed from the Comprehensive article nominations page:

Time elapsed Day 1
24 hours
Day 2
48 hours
Day 3
72 hours
Day 4
96 hours
Day 5
120 hours
Day 6
144 hours
Day 7
168 hours
More than 168 hours (more than one week)
Required votesCannot pass Can pass with four EduCorps votes Can pass with three EduCorps votes or at least five votes, of which at least two must be EduCorps votes
  • Remove {{CAnom}} from article page and add "comp" to {{Eras}}.
  • Add the following to talk page with appropriate dates and IDs (the number at the end of the URL in the page history). The first date is when the article was nominated, and the corresponding ID should be the revision of the article when {{CAnom}} was added. The second date is the date that the article was given CA status, and the corresponding ID is that of the revision when the CA circle was added. For example, on Holding Back the Tide the first ID is 3185636 and the second ID is 3201624.
{{CA}}
{{Ahh}}
{{Ahm
|date=Nominated date
|oldid=Nominated ID
|process=CAN
|result=Success
}}
{{Ahm
|date={{subst:CURRENTMONTHNAME}} {{subst:CURRENTDAY}}, {{subst:CURRENTYEAR}}
|link=Wookieepedia:Comprehensive article nominations/{{Subst:PAGENAME}}
|process=CA
|oldid=Successful ID
}}
{{Ahf|status=CA}}
{{Subst:CA archive|successful}}
  • Remove this line from the bottom of the nomination page.
<noinclude>[[Category:Comprehensive article nominations|{{SUBPAGENAME}}]]</noinclude>
  • Add this line to the bottom of the nomination page.
</div>
  • Add article to CAN history, giving start and end dates (yyyy/mm/dd) and outcome with link to archived vote.
  • Add article to Wookieepedia:Comprehensive articles.
    • When adding article to Wookieepedia:Comprehensive articles, display it like [[Bob (naval officer)]] or [[Victorious (Acclamator-class)|''Victorious'' (''Acclamator''-class)]], as opposed to [[Bob (naval officer)|Bob]] or [[Victorious (Acclamator-class)|''Victorious'']].

Failed nominationsEdit

Nominations that are inactive with outstanding objections after one week may be eliminated from the nomination list with a consensus of at least 3 EC support votes. This consensus of 3 support votes may alternatively be obtained from present users in IRC.

CANs may be closed prematurely with a consensus of at least 3 EC support votes if they fall below the required standard and cannot realistically be fixed. This consensus of at least 3 EC support votes may alternatively be obtained from present users in IRC, in which case a note will be left on the CAN page that the nomination has been removed via EC consensus.

Any nomination may be closed early at the request of the original nominator without the need for a consensus.

Removing failed nominationsEdit

  • Remove {{CAnom}} from article page.
  • Add the following to talk page with appropriate dates and IDs (the number at the end of the URL in the page history). The first date is when the article was nominated, and the corresponding ID should be the revision of the article when {{CAnom}} was added (for articles nominated during the trial period, the corresponding ID should be the revision that was "current" as of the date/time of nomination). The second date is the date that the nomination was removed, and the corresponding ID is that of the revision when {{CAnom}} was removed.
{{Ahh}}
{{Ahm
|date=Nominated date
|oldid=Nominated ID
|process=CAN
|result=Failure
}}
{{Ahm
|date={{subst:CURRENTMONTHNAME}} {{subst:CURRENTDAY}}, {{subst:CURRENTYEAR}}
|link=Wookieepedia:Comprehensive article nominations/{{Subst:PAGENAME}}
|process=FCAN
|oldid=Failed ID
}}
{{Ahf|status=FCAN}}
{{Subst:CA archive|unsuccessful}}
  • Remove this line from the bottom of the nomination page.
<noinclude>[[Category:Comprehensive article nominations|{{SUBPAGENAME}}]]</noinclude>
  • Add this line to the bottom of the nomination page.
</div>
  • Add article to CAN history, giving start and end dates (yyyy/mm/dd) and outcome with link to archived vote.

Overriding CAN objectionsEdit

EduCorps members have the power to strike objections on the Comprehensive Article nomination page provided the objection has been addressed and the original objector has been absent for at least a week after an "objection addressed" comment is left on the CA nom page. This requires a quorum of at least 2 EduCorps members approving the removal of the objection, and less than 2 opposed. Additionally, CAN objections can be struck by an EduCorps member (as well as by any admin) if they do not fall under one of the rules. No vote is required.

To initiate a vote to override an objection, add the following under the CAN's comments section:

====Vote to strike objection (EC only)====

The EduCorps member who initiates the vote should state clearly which objection needs striking and why. All EduCorps members should use the {{EC}} template when voting, and clearly indicate whether they support or oppose overriding the objection.

When the decision has been taken to override an objection, add the following as a comment under the objection, in addition to striking it:

{{Ecstrike|~~~~~}}

CA status reviewEdit

The EduCorps has the ability to strip an article of CA status.

ProbationEdit

With the approval of at least 3 EduCorps members and less than 2 opposed, an article being considered for removal of CA status can be placed on probation as follows:

  • Add the following to the top of the article (if the article has been previously reviewed by the EduCorps, use a new name for the parameter):
{{Cacleanup|{{Subst:PAGENAME}}}}
  • Follow the redlink in the above template and add the following to the page:
<div style="background:#EEEEEE; border:1px solid #AAAAAA; padding:5px">'''[[Main Page|Wookieepedia]] &gt; [[Wookieepedia:EduCorps]] &gt; {{PAGENAME}}'''</div>
[[Category:Wookieepedia EduCorps CA review]]

<!-- write after this line, please -->
==[[Article name]]==

===Things to do===

===Removal of CA status===

===Comments===
  • List the issues that need rectifying under "Things to do" and state the meeting at which the article was placed on probation under "Removal of CA status."

After a probation period of at least two weeks, a second EduCorps vote is required to decide whether or not to remove CA status. This vote requires 3 EduCorps members to agree on the outcome, with less than 2 disagreeing.

Keeping CA statusEdit

If CA status is kept:

  • Remove {{CAcleanup}} from article page
  • Add the following to talk page with appropriate dates and IDs (the number at the end of the URL in the page history). The first date is when the article was nominated for removal and the corresponding ID should be the revision of the article when {{CAcleanup}} was added (if the template wasn't added on the nomination date, pick the revision as of the date and time of nomination). The second date is the date that the removal nomination was archived and the corresponding ID is that of the revision when {{CAcleanup}} was removed. Using a GA as an example, on Zayne Carrick the first ID is 1982312 and the second ID is 2059191.
{{Ahm
|date=Nomination date
|oldid=Nominated ID
|process=CAR
|result=Kept
}}
{{Ahm
|date={{subst:CURRENTMONTHNAME}} {{subst:CURRENTDAY}}, {{subst:CURRENTYEAR}}
|link=Wookieepedia:EC/{{Subst:PAGENAME}}
|process=CA
|oldid=Kept ID
}}
{{Ahf|status=CA}}

Removing CA statusEdit

If CA status is removed:

  • Remove {{Cacleanup}} from article page and change "comp" to "fca" in {{eras}}
  • Add the following to talk page (replacing {{Ahf|status=CA}}) with appropriate dates and IDs (the number at the end of the URL in the page history). The first date is when the article was nominated for removal and the corresponding ID should be the revision of the article when {{Cacleanup}} was added (if the template wasn't added on the nomination date, pick the revision as of the date and time of nomination). The second date is the date that the article was stripped of CA status and the corresponding ID is that of the revision when the CA circle was removed. Using a GA as an example, on Missile Boat the first ID is 2056762 and the second ID is 2095534.
{{Ahm
|date=Nomination date
|oldid=Nominated ID
|process=CAR
|result=Removed
}}
{{Ahm
|date={{subst:CURRENTMONTHNAME}} {{subst:CURRENTDAY}}, {{subst:CURRENTYEAR}}
|link=Wookieepedia:EC/{{Subst:PAGENAME}}
|process=FCA
|oldid=Removed ID
}}
{{Ahf|status=FCA}}

Reduxing CAsEdit

If a CA is decided to undergo a review on the Redux page, do this:

  • Add the following lines to the bottom of the redux page:
==[[Article name]]==
*'''Redux comments''': Reduxed per <meeting number>.
*'''Date added''': {{subst:CURRENTMONTHNAME}} {{subst:CURRENTDAY}}, {{subst:CURRENTYEAR}}

===(+0)===
'''Support'''

'''Object'''

'''Comments'''
  • Add {{CAredux}} to the top of the reduxed CA. If the article is already under probation, replace {{CAcleanup}} with {{CAredux}}, changing the link to the review page to the link to the article's Redux entry.

Keeping CA status following ReduxEdit

When the article has received three supporting votes from EduCorps members, do this:

  • Remove {{CAredux}} from the reduxed page.
  • Add the following code to the article talk page:
{{Ahh}}
{{Ahm
|date=Probation date
|oldid=Probation ID
|process=CAR
|result=Kept
}}
{{Ahm
|date={{subst:CURRENTMONTHNAME}} {{subst:CURRENTDAY}}, {{subst:CURRENTYEAR}}
|link=Wookieepedia:EC/{{Subst:PAGENAME}}
|process=CA
|oldid=Kept ID
}}
{{Ahf|status=CA}}
  • Follow the link (which will be a redlink if the article wasn't on probation before it was reduxed) to the review page.
  • If the page does not yet exist (if it wasn't on probation before), add this to the page:
<div style="background:#EEEEEE; border:1px solid #AAAAAA; padding:5px">'''[[Main Page|Wookieepedia]] &gt; [[Wookieepedia:EduCorps]] &gt; {{PAGENAME}}'''</div>
[[Category:Wookieepedia EduCorps CA review]]

<!-- write after this line, please -->
==[[Article name]]==
===Removal of CA status===
*Reduxed at <meeting number>. ~~~~
*Kept on {{subst:CURRENTMONTHNAME}} {{subst:CURRENTDAY}}, {{subst:CURRENTYEAR}}. ~~~~

===Redux review===

===Comments===
  • If the review page already exists, just add the Redux review heading.
  • Copy the redux review from the redux page, and add it under the heading like this:
===Redux review===
{{subst:CAredux archive|kept}}
redux review goes here
</div>
  • Remove the review from the redux page.

Removing CA status following ReduxEdit

If the article fails Redux review due to three weeks' inactivity on objections or removal at an EduCorps meeting, do this:

  • Remove {{CAredux}} from article page and change "comp" to "fca" in {{Eras}}.
  • Add the following code to the article talk page:
{{Ahh}}
{{Ahm
|date=Probation date
|oldid=Probation ID
|process=CAR
|result=Removed
}}
{{Ahm
|date={{subst:CURRENTMONTHNAME}} {{subst:CURRENTDAY}}, {{subst:CURRENTYEAR}}
|link=Wookieepedia:EC/{{Subst:PAGENAME}}
|process=FCA
|oldid=Removed ID
}}
{{Ahf|status=FCA}}
  • Follow the link (which will be a redlink if the article wasn't on probation before it was reduxed) to the review page.
  • If the page does not yet exist (if it wasn't on probation before), add this to the page:
<div style="background:#EEEEEE; border:1px solid #AAAAAA; padding:5px">'''[[Main Page|Wookieepedia]] > [[Wookieepedia:EduCorps]] > {{PAGENAME}}'''</div>
[[Category:Wookieepedia EduCorps CA review]]

<!-- write after this line, please -->
==[[Article name]]==
===Removal of CA status===
*Reduxed at <meeting number>. ~~~~
*Removed on {{subst:CURRENTMONTHNAME}} {{subst:CURRENTDAY}}, {{subst:CURRENTYEAR}}. ~~~~

===Redux review===

===Comments===
  • If the review page already exists, just add the Redux review heading.
  • Copy the redux review from the redux page, and add it under the heading like this:
===Redux review===
{{subst:CAredux archive|lost}}
redux review goes here
</div>
  • Remove the review from the redux page.
  • Replace {{CA}} with {{FormerCA}} on the talk page. A parameter can be used if the EduCorps review page differs from the article name.
  • On the EduCorps review page, state the meeting at which the article's CA status was removed under "Removal of CA status."
  • Remove article from Wookieepedia:Comprehensive articles.

Striking items from the meeting agendaEdit

To remove an item from a future meeting agenda, a consensus of three ECs is needed. This can be achieved via IRC or using the meeting page itself. If you use the meeting page, format it like this:

*[[Article]] - update needed. --ExampleUser1
**Updated. --ExampleUser2
***'''Vote to remove article from meeting agenda (EC only)'''
***{{EC}} ~~~~

When three ECs have signed, the article can be struck from the agenda.