Wikia

Wookieepedia

Wookieepedia:Consensus

Talk1
113,011pages on
this wiki
Information icon

This page is considered an official policy on Wookieepedia.

It has wide acceptance among editors and is considered a standard that everyone must follow. Please use the Consensus track to propose changes to this policy.

Wookieepedia policies
Article policies
Attribution · Be bold · Deletion policy
Layout Guide · Layout Guide/Out-of-universe
Manual of Style · MOS: Proper use of the dash
Neutral point of view · Notability (fan projects)
Naming policy · Protection policy · Sourcing
Spoilers · Talk Pages · Three-revert rule · Trivia · Vandalism
User policies
Administrative autonomy · Blocking policy · Equality
No personal attacks · Privacy policy
Signature policy · Single-issue voters
Sock puppetry · User image policy · User page policy
Site policies
Canon · Civility · Consensus · Copyrights · Images
Interviews · Policy and consensus updates
Site feature policy · What Wookieepedia is not
Proposed policies
Bots
Guidelines
Avoid instruction creep · Avoid self-references
Dispute resolution
Don't disrupt Wookieepedia to prove a point · Soft redirect
[edit]

In many cases, changes to wiki-wide policy and/or changes to individual articles are determined by consensus. In the absence of consensus, these issues may be settled by a majority or supermajority of Wookieepedians polled (as mediated by one or more administrators).

When an issue is settled by either of these methods, attempts by any individual to counteract or violate these decisions without community support (as determined by a renewed discussion of the issue with participation equal to or greater than the original discussion) will be considered vandalism/disruptive editing under the blocking policy. A blocked user's votes do not count on any active discussion or vote of any type (except WP:QOTD at the discretion of an administrator) for the entire duration of the block.

For community-wide consensus discussions, please visit Forum:Consensus track.

Trash compactor

The Trash compactor is a decision-making process that is utilized by the Wookieepedia community to determine the fate of articles nominated for deletion. Similar to the consensus track, Trash compactor threads are governed by the following guidelines:

  • Trash compactor discussions should, in general, last two weeks.
  • An admin may close a TC discussion earlier, after one week from the start of voting on an issue, if the votes overwhelmingly support one option: keeping the article in question, deleting the article, merging two or more articles, or any other proposal advanced in the discussion.
  • If consensus is unclear, admins should wait at least two weeks before closing the discussion with a result of "no consensus." A "no consensus" result will default to keeping the article.
  • Admins may also close a discussion with a result of "no consensus" after less than two weeks, providing that the admin closing the discussion quickly starts a new TC discussion with a different or more clearly defined set of options which, based on the first discussion, are more likely to lead to a consensus.

Consensus track

With regards to the process of Consensus track forums which are discussed and debated among the entire community, it is the responsibility of administrators both to provide input on consensus track threads, as well as closing the threads when they are finished.

Two weeks is provided as a minimum time frame for thread length, though a thread should only be closed if it is clear that a consensus has been reached, or if no consensus has been reached and the thread has not been edited by a vote-eligible Wookieepedian in five days after at least two weeks of being active. After one week from the start of voting on an issue, if the votes overwhelmingly support one option, the thread may be closed early. Also, for threads closed by section (some of the MOS ones, for example), each section would have to be dormant for five days after a minimum of two weeks in order to be closed, not necessarily the entire forum; after one week from the start of voting on an issue, if the votes overwhelmingly support one option, the section may be closed early. If that makes sense. These length guidelines also apply to TC threads. This lack of activity and consensus is an indication that a community agreement is not forthcoming. Should a thread be closed, it is the responsibility of the administration to properly address the result of the thread and apply it to the site and its policies as need be.

For consensus to be achieved, a minimum of ten Wookieepedians must contribute a vote or statement. Consensus track threads with 10-16 voters will need a 3 to 1 ratio of votes for passage; consensus track threads with 17 to 24 voters will need a 5 to 2 ratio of votes for passage; consensus track threads with more than 25 votes can be passed by a 2:1 ratio of votes/opinions posted on the thread. These ratios also apply to trash compactor threads as well.

Additionally, it is regarded as bad form and against proper practice to close a consensus track thread in which an individual administrator has been heavily involved, though all consensus track closings fall under administrative discretion.

Modifying discussions

Once a proposal is offered in Consensus Track and Trash Compactor forums, it must remain unchanged following the commencement of voting unless:

  1. All users who have cast votes prior to the desired change to be included are directly contacted, or the alteration to the vote is rendered invalid; or…
  2. Individual amendments are drafted to alter to the topical vote, but must pass separately within the same CT or TC page and adhere to rules of consensus.

Exceptions to this include slight tweaks to wording or punctuation that do not alter the intended approved meaning of the vote but are done for clarity when incorporating them onto policy pages.

Productivity requirement

Regardless of the overall total number of edits, a user's combined total of content namespace, Wookieepedia:, and MediaWiki: edits must be at least double the combined total of Forum:, User:, and User_talk: namespace edits in order to vote on any matters affecting the site or other users. This does not alter the minimum requirement of fifty non-reverted main namespace edits required to vote on anything. This does exclude "fun" votes such as Mister/Miss Star Wars and WP:QOTD.

See also

Around Wikia's network

Random Wiki